‘Free Palestine’ note found in Chanukah gift order from Bloomingdale’s
A customer says a Bloomingdale’s worker slipped a ‘free Palestine’ note into her Chanukah order. The retailer’s response has deepened the dispute.
Jessica Russak-Hoffman
2
Published by
JNS

Entrance to a Bloomingdale’s department store in New Jersey. Photo courtesy of Curlyrnd via Wikimedia Commons.

What was meant to be a holiday gift from Bloomingdale’s instead sparked outrage online after a customer alleged a store employee placed a handwritten “free Palestine” note into the package of Chanukah pajamas, prompting an internal investigation by the retailer.
Denials
“Yesterday, on the first night of Chanukah, my boyfriend gave me a gift he ordered from Bloomingdale’s. Holiday pajamas covered in Jewish stars from P.J. Salvage,” Arielle Harris said in a social media video shared on Dec. 15. The note, seemingly written on a store-branded card, was tucked into the clothing on top of a receipt, she said.
“This never should have happened, and Bloomingdale’s needs to answer for their employees,” Harris said. She added that her boyfriend, Andrew Jones, had not opened the package before giving it to her.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Craziest part is how many commenters think I faked this,” Jones wrote. “Typical denials of anti-Semitism. My heart dropped when this happened. Totally twisted a nice night of celebrating.”
Under investigation
Jones and Harris told JNS that a senior Bloomingdale’s executive contacted them with a “preliminary apology” and invited the couple to speak with them more.
Jennifer Chadroff, director of brand communications for Bloomingdale’s, confirmed that the brand had connected with the customers and that the “matter is currently under investigation.”
“This was an unauthorized and unacceptable act,” she told JNS.
“Antisemitism, or discrimination in any form, has absolutely no place in our business and does not align with our values or our care for our customers,” Chadroff said. “Please know we are treating this with the utmost seriousness.
Jewish leaders condemned the alleged incident after it spread online.
“A ‘free Palestine’ note in a Bloomingdale’s Chanukah gift. No limits. No shame,” stated Deborah Lipstadt, former U.S. special envoy to monitor and combat anti-Semitism.
Joan Leslie McGill, executive director of the U.S. Israel Education Association, stated, “Jewish identity does not require permission, and it will not be intimidated.”
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
‘Free Palestine’ note found in Chanukah gift order from Bloomingdale’s
A customer says a Bloomingdale’s worker slipped a ‘free Palestine’ note into her Chanukah order. The retailer’s response has deepened the dispute.
Jessica Russak-Hoffman
2
Published by
JNS

Entrance to a Bloomingdale’s department store in New Jersey. Photo courtesy of Curlyrnd via Wikimedia Commons.

What was meant to be a holiday gift from Bloomingdale’s instead sparked outrage online after a customer alleged a store employee placed a handwritten “free Palestine” note into the package of Chanukah pajamas, prompting an internal investigation by the retailer.
Denials
“Yesterday, on the first night of Chanukah, my boyfriend gave me a gift he ordered from Bloomingdale’s. Holiday pajamas covered in Jewish stars from P.J. Salvage,” Arielle Harris said in a social media video shared on Dec. 15. The note, seemingly written on a store-branded card, was tucked into the clothing on top of a receipt, she said.
“This never should have happened, and Bloomingdale’s needs to answer for their employees,” Harris said. She added that her boyfriend, Andrew Jones, had not opened the package before giving it to her.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Craziest part is how many commenters think I faked this,” Jones wrote. “Typical denials of anti-Semitism. My heart dropped when this happened. Totally twisted a nice night of celebrating.”
Under investigation
Jones and Harris told JNS that a senior Bloomingdale’s executive contacted them with a “preliminary apology” and invited the couple to speak with them more.
Jennifer Chadroff, director of brand communications for Bloomingdale’s, confirmed that the brand had connected with the customers and that the “matter is currently under investigation.”
“This was an unauthorized and unacceptable act,” she told JNS.
“Antisemitism, or discrimination in any form, has absolutely no place in our business and does not align with our values or our care for our customers,” Chadroff said. “Please know we are treating this with the utmost seriousness.
Jewish leaders condemned the alleged incident after it spread online.
“A ‘free Palestine’ note in a Bloomingdale’s Chanukah gift. No limits. No shame,” stated Deborah Lipstadt, former U.S. special envoy to monitor and combat anti-Semitism.
Joan Leslie McGill, executive director of the U.S. Israel Education Association, stated, “Jewish identity does not require permission, and it will not be intimidated.”
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
‘Free Palestine’ note found in Chanukah gift order from Bloomingdale’s
A customer says a Bloomingdale’s worker slipped a ‘free Palestine’ note into her Chanukah order. The retailer’s response has deepened the dispute.
Jessica Russak-Hoffman
2
Published by
JNS

Entrance to a Bloomingdale’s department store in New Jersey. Photo courtesy of Curlyrnd via Wikimedia Commons.

What was meant to be a holiday gift from Bloomingdale’s instead sparked outrage online after a customer alleged a store employee placed a handwritten “free Palestine” note into the package of Chanukah pajamas, prompting an internal investigation by the retailer.
Denials
“Yesterday, on the first night of Chanukah, my boyfriend gave me a gift he ordered from Bloomingdale’s. Holiday pajamas covered in Jewish stars from P.J. Salvage,” Arielle Harris said in a social media video shared on Dec. 15. The note, seemingly written on a store-branded card, was tucked into the clothing on top of a receipt, she said.
“This never should have happened, and Bloomingdale’s needs to answer for their employees,” Harris said. She added that her boyfriend, Andrew Jones, had not opened the package before giving it to her.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Craziest part is how many commenters think I faked this,” Jones wrote. “Typical denials of anti-Semitism. My heart dropped when this happened. Totally twisted a nice night of celebrating.”
Under investigation
Jones and Harris told JNS that a senior Bloomingdale’s executive contacted them with a “preliminary apology” and invited the couple to speak with them more.
Jennifer Chadroff, director of brand communications for Bloomingdale’s, confirmed that the brand had connected with the customers and that the “matter is currently under investigation.”
“This was an unauthorized and unacceptable act,” she told JNS.
“Antisemitism, or discrimination in any form, has absolutely no place in our business and does not align with our values or our care for our customers,” Chadroff said. “Please know we are treating this with the utmost seriousness.
Jewish leaders condemned the alleged incident after it spread online.
“A ‘free Palestine’ note in a Bloomingdale’s Chanukah gift. No limits. No shame,” stated Deborah Lipstadt, former U.S. special envoy to monitor and combat anti-Semitism.
Joan Leslie McGill, executive director of the U.S. Israel Education Association, stated, “Jewish identity does not require permission, and it will not be intimidated.”
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
‘Free Palestine’ note found in Chanukah gift order from Bloomingdale’s
A customer says a Bloomingdale’s worker slipped a ‘free Palestine’ note into her Chanukah order. The retailer’s response has deepened the dispute.
Jessica Russak-Hoffman
2
Published by
JNS

Entrance to a Bloomingdale’s department store in New Jersey. Photo courtesy of Curlyrnd via Wikimedia Commons.

What was meant to be a holiday gift from Bloomingdale’s instead sparked outrage online after a customer alleged a store employee placed a handwritten “free Palestine” note into the package of Chanukah pajamas, prompting an internal investigation by the retailer.
Denials
“Yesterday, on the first night of Chanukah, my boyfriend gave me a gift he ordered from Bloomingdale’s. Holiday pajamas covered in Jewish stars from P.J. Salvage,” Arielle Harris said in a social media video shared on Dec. 15. The note, seemingly written on a store-branded card, was tucked into the clothing on top of a receipt, she said.
“This never should have happened, and Bloomingdale’s needs to answer for their employees,” Harris said. She added that her boyfriend, Andrew Jones, had not opened the package before giving it to her.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Craziest part is how many commenters think I faked this,” Jones wrote. “Typical denials of anti-Semitism. My heart dropped when this happened. Totally twisted a nice night of celebrating.”
Under investigation
Jones and Harris told JNS that a senior Bloomingdale’s executive contacted them with a “preliminary apology” and invited the couple to speak with them more.
Jennifer Chadroff, director of brand communications for Bloomingdale’s, confirmed that the brand had connected with the customers and that the “matter is currently under investigation.”
“This was an unauthorized and unacceptable act,” she told JNS.
“Antisemitism, or discrimination in any form, has absolutely no place in our business and does not align with our values or our care for our customers,” Chadroff said. “Please know we are treating this with the utmost seriousness.
Jewish leaders condemned the alleged incident after it spread online.
“A ‘free Palestine’ note in a Bloomingdale’s Chanukah gift. No limits. No shame,” stated Deborah Lipstadt, former U.S. special envoy to monitor and combat anti-Semitism.
Joan Leslie McGill, executive director of the U.S. Israel Education Association, stated, “Jewish identity does not require permission, and it will not be intimidated.”
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related News

Local
Events
Clifton Park Jewish Woman’s Circle Gala featuring Sara Esther Crispe planned for July 14
The Clifton Park Jewish Woman’s Circle holds its 18th annual gala on June 14 in Malta, with international speaker Sara Esther Crispe headlining.
The Jewish World Team
June 11, 2026

Local
Events
Clifton Park Chabad launches new JLI course: Sinai and Civics
Clifton Park Chabad is offering a new JLI course on Jewish values, civic responsibility and Torah’s role in democracy, open to all adults.
The Jewish World Team
June 11, 2026

Local
Community News
Shalom Food Pantry Battle of the BBQs set for June 21; Fund-raiser to help the hungry
The ninth annual Battle of the BBQs returns June 21 at the Albany JCC, raising funds for Shalom Food Pantry’s year-round hunger relief efforts.
The Jewish World Team
June 4, 2026

Local
Events
Clifton Park Jewish Woman’s Circle Gala featuring Sara Esther Crispe planned for July 14
The Clifton Park Jewish Woman’s Circle holds its 18th annual gala on June 14 in Malta, with international speaker Sara Esther Crispe headlining.
The Jewish World Team
June 11, 2026

Local
Events
Clifton Park Chabad launches new JLI course: Sinai and Civics
Clifton Park Chabad is offering a new JLI course on Jewish values, civic responsibility and Torah’s role in democracy, open to all adults.
The Jewish World Team
June 11, 2026

Local
Community News
Shalom Food Pantry Battle of the BBQs set for June 21; Fund-raiser to help the hungry
The ninth annual Battle of the BBQs returns June 21 at the Albany JCC, raising funds for Shalom Food Pantry’s year-round hunger relief efforts.
The Jewish World Team
June 4, 2026

Local
Community News
Union Of Reform Judaism president speaks at Beth Emeth
Over 250 community members gathered at Albany’s Beth Emeth to hear URJ President Rabbi Rick Jacobs speak on the future of Israel.
The Jewish World Team
June 4, 2026
© 2026 The Jewish World · Since 1965 - The Capital Region's gateway to Jewish life
Designed and Developed by Ta-Da Studios
© 2026 The Jewish World · Since 1965 - The Capital Region's gateway to Jewish life
Designed and Developed by Ta-Da Studios
© 2026 The Jewish World · Since 1965 - The Capital Region's gateway to Jewish life
Designed and Developed by Ta-Da Studios
© 2026 The Jewish World · Since 1965 - The Capital Region's gateway to Jewish life
Designed and Developed by Ta-Da Studios
