Why I deleted my data from 23andMe
Woman with Ashkenazi ancestry deleted 23andMe data after bankruptcy announcement, citing concerns about genetic privacy and historical persecution.
Ricki Lewis
3
Published by
The Jewish World

Ilustration of DNA molecules. Graphic courtesy of Sciencerf, dDeposit Photos
When consumer DNA testing company 23andMe announced on March 23 that it had filed for bankruptcy, I wasn’t alarmed — at first.
If someone wanted to know that I have a mutation for polycystic liver disease, or that I have more Neanderthal DNA than most folks, so be it. I’d never paid attention to the ancestry part of the picture. A pie chart of one color, depicting 100% Ashkenazi heritage, isn’t as interesting as a chart from someone who is, say, 10% Native American, 50% Nigerian, 30% Scottish, and a sprinkling of other ethnicities, like a multicolor fabric of entwined history.
Haunting parallels
But could those boring, one-color ancestry pie charts become a label, like yellow stars once were for being Jewish? That’s a growing concern as haunting parallels to 1930s Germany emerge here in the U.S. The alternate realities of Sinclair Lewis’s novel It Can’t Happen Here, Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America, and the TV series The Man In the High Castle, have become the stuff of nightmares.
Where do the pie charts come from? Algorithms deduce dozens of sites of origin by following families that go back at least five generations staying in the same place, and comparing their DNA data to people in other geographic regions.
But I didn’t need a pie chart to tell me I was Ashkenazi.
I knew the story of how my grandmother Sarah had escaped a pogrom in Russia, on the brink of adolescence, to come to the United States in 1905. She was lucky. A few years later, she escaped the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire because she had a cold that Saturday morning and stayed home.
I think of being Ashkenazi as a cultural identity, not so much a sequence of DNA bases. I have curly hair, Ashkenazi facial features, love comedy and music, and appreciate stuffed derma and knishes.
ADVERTISEMENT
What could happen?
23andMe had indicated trouble brewing over six months ago. My half-sister Sara Jane alerted me in March to the news that the company could be up for sale. (We had found each other, and 10 other half-siblings, a few years ago thanks to Ancestry.com, confirmed through 23andMe.)
I told Sara Jane that I was proud of my Neanderthal heritage and my health was fine, but she reminded me of the one-colored ancestry pie chart in my 23andMe account. If another company takes over, what happens to the ethnicity report, the unicolor pie chart?
We don’t know.
But in this age of upheaval and uncertainty, a chart that indicates Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry can turn from a badge of pride to a source of concern, depending upon circumstances that we cannot predict.
I advise deleting your data.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Why I deleted my data from 23andMe
Woman with Ashkenazi ancestry deleted 23andMe data after bankruptcy announcement, citing concerns about genetic privacy and historical persecution.
Ricki Lewis
3
Published by
The Jewish World

Ilustration of DNA molecules. Graphic courtesy of Sciencerf, dDeposit Photos
When consumer DNA testing company 23andMe announced on March 23 that it had filed for bankruptcy, I wasn’t alarmed — at first.
If someone wanted to know that I have a mutation for polycystic liver disease, or that I have more Neanderthal DNA than most folks, so be it. I’d never paid attention to the ancestry part of the picture. A pie chart of one color, depicting 100% Ashkenazi heritage, isn’t as interesting as a chart from someone who is, say, 10% Native American, 50% Nigerian, 30% Scottish, and a sprinkling of other ethnicities, like a multicolor fabric of entwined history.
Haunting parallels
But could those boring, one-color ancestry pie charts become a label, like yellow stars once were for being Jewish? That’s a growing concern as haunting parallels to 1930s Germany emerge here in the U.S. The alternate realities of Sinclair Lewis’s novel It Can’t Happen Here, Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America, and the TV series The Man In the High Castle, have become the stuff of nightmares.
Where do the pie charts come from? Algorithms deduce dozens of sites of origin by following families that go back at least five generations staying in the same place, and comparing their DNA data to people in other geographic regions.
But I didn’t need a pie chart to tell me I was Ashkenazi.
I knew the story of how my grandmother Sarah had escaped a pogrom in Russia, on the brink of adolescence, to come to the United States in 1905. She was lucky. A few years later, she escaped the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire because she had a cold that Saturday morning and stayed home.
I think of being Ashkenazi as a cultural identity, not so much a sequence of DNA bases. I have curly hair, Ashkenazi facial features, love comedy and music, and appreciate stuffed derma and knishes.
ADVERTISEMENT
What could happen?
23andMe had indicated trouble brewing over six months ago. My half-sister Sara Jane alerted me in March to the news that the company could be up for sale. (We had found each other, and 10 other half-siblings, a few years ago thanks to Ancestry.com, confirmed through 23andMe.)
I told Sara Jane that I was proud of my Neanderthal heritage and my health was fine, but she reminded me of the one-colored ancestry pie chart in my 23andMe account. If another company takes over, what happens to the ethnicity report, the unicolor pie chart?
We don’t know.
But in this age of upheaval and uncertainty, a chart that indicates Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry can turn from a badge of pride to a source of concern, depending upon circumstances that we cannot predict.
I advise deleting your data.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Why I deleted my data from 23andMe
Woman with Ashkenazi ancestry deleted 23andMe data after bankruptcy announcement, citing concerns about genetic privacy and historical persecution.
Ricki Lewis
3
Published by
The Jewish World

Ilustration of DNA molecules. Graphic courtesy of Sciencerf, dDeposit Photos
When consumer DNA testing company 23andMe announced on March 23 that it had filed for bankruptcy, I wasn’t alarmed — at first.
If someone wanted to know that I have a mutation for polycystic liver disease, or that I have more Neanderthal DNA than most folks, so be it. I’d never paid attention to the ancestry part of the picture. A pie chart of one color, depicting 100% Ashkenazi heritage, isn’t as interesting as a chart from someone who is, say, 10% Native American, 50% Nigerian, 30% Scottish, and a sprinkling of other ethnicities, like a multicolor fabric of entwined history.
Haunting parallels
But could those boring, one-color ancestry pie charts become a label, like yellow stars once were for being Jewish? That’s a growing concern as haunting parallels to 1930s Germany emerge here in the U.S. The alternate realities of Sinclair Lewis’s novel It Can’t Happen Here, Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America, and the TV series The Man In the High Castle, have become the stuff of nightmares.
Where do the pie charts come from? Algorithms deduce dozens of sites of origin by following families that go back at least five generations staying in the same place, and comparing their DNA data to people in other geographic regions.
But I didn’t need a pie chart to tell me I was Ashkenazi.
I knew the story of how my grandmother Sarah had escaped a pogrom in Russia, on the brink of adolescence, to come to the United States in 1905. She was lucky. A few years later, she escaped the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire because she had a cold that Saturday morning and stayed home.
I think of being Ashkenazi as a cultural identity, not so much a sequence of DNA bases. I have curly hair, Ashkenazi facial features, love comedy and music, and appreciate stuffed derma and knishes.
ADVERTISEMENT
What could happen?
23andMe had indicated trouble brewing over six months ago. My half-sister Sara Jane alerted me in March to the news that the company could be up for sale. (We had found each other, and 10 other half-siblings, a few years ago thanks to Ancestry.com, confirmed through 23andMe.)
I told Sara Jane that I was proud of my Neanderthal heritage and my health was fine, but she reminded me of the one-colored ancestry pie chart in my 23andMe account. If another company takes over, what happens to the ethnicity report, the unicolor pie chart?
We don’t know.
But in this age of upheaval and uncertainty, a chart that indicates Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry can turn from a badge of pride to a source of concern, depending upon circumstances that we cannot predict.
I advise deleting your data.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Why I deleted my data from 23andMe
Woman with Ashkenazi ancestry deleted 23andMe data after bankruptcy announcement, citing concerns about genetic privacy and historical persecution.
Ricki Lewis
3
Published by
The Jewish World

Ilustration of DNA molecules. Graphic courtesy of Sciencerf, dDeposit Photos
When consumer DNA testing company 23andMe announced on March 23 that it had filed for bankruptcy, I wasn’t alarmed — at first.
If someone wanted to know that I have a mutation for polycystic liver disease, or that I have more Neanderthal DNA than most folks, so be it. I’d never paid attention to the ancestry part of the picture. A pie chart of one color, depicting 100% Ashkenazi heritage, isn’t as interesting as a chart from someone who is, say, 10% Native American, 50% Nigerian, 30% Scottish, and a sprinkling of other ethnicities, like a multicolor fabric of entwined history.
Haunting parallels
But could those boring, one-color ancestry pie charts become a label, like yellow stars once were for being Jewish? That’s a growing concern as haunting parallels to 1930s Germany emerge here in the U.S. The alternate realities of Sinclair Lewis’s novel It Can’t Happen Here, Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America, and the TV series The Man In the High Castle, have become the stuff of nightmares.
Where do the pie charts come from? Algorithms deduce dozens of sites of origin by following families that go back at least five generations staying in the same place, and comparing their DNA data to people in other geographic regions.
But I didn’t need a pie chart to tell me I was Ashkenazi.
I knew the story of how my grandmother Sarah had escaped a pogrom in Russia, on the brink of adolescence, to come to the United States in 1905. She was lucky. A few years later, she escaped the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire because she had a cold that Saturday morning and stayed home.
I think of being Ashkenazi as a cultural identity, not so much a sequence of DNA bases. I have curly hair, Ashkenazi facial features, love comedy and music, and appreciate stuffed derma and knishes.
ADVERTISEMENT
What could happen?
23andMe had indicated trouble brewing over six months ago. My half-sister Sara Jane alerted me in March to the news that the company could be up for sale. (We had found each other, and 10 other half-siblings, a few years ago thanks to Ancestry.com, confirmed through 23andMe.)
I told Sara Jane that I was proud of my Neanderthal heritage and my health was fine, but she reminded me of the one-colored ancestry pie chart in my 23andMe account. If another company takes over, what happens to the ethnicity report, the unicolor pie chart?
We don’t know.
But in this age of upheaval and uncertainty, a chart that indicates Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry can turn from a badge of pride to a source of concern, depending upon circumstances that we cannot predict.
I advise deleting your data.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related News

World
Global
World War II family saga sifts through patriotism, identity, acclimation and pluck
A debut book follows three Jewish brothers from Philadelphia through their WWII service, exploring family, identity, and Jewish continuity.
Steve Linde
June 11, 2026

World
Global
British Museum postpones lecture on ancient Israel, cites ‘security concerns’
The British Museum postponed a talk on ancient Israel and Judah, citing security concerns after learning attendees planned to disrupt the event.
JNS
June 4, 2026

World
Israel & Middle East
Israel’s Noam Bettan places second behind Bulgaria at Eurovision
Noam Bettan ended his trilingual “Michelle” with “Am Yisrael Chai” before 160 million viewers, defying boos and a five-country boycott.
Steve Linde
JNS
May 21, 2026

World
Global
World War II family saga sifts through patriotism, identity, acclimation and pluck
A debut book follows three Jewish brothers from Philadelphia through their WWII service, exploring family, identity, and Jewish continuity.
Steve Linde
June 11, 2026

World
Global
British Museum postpones lecture on ancient Israel, cites ‘security concerns’
The British Museum postponed a talk on ancient Israel and Judah, citing security concerns after learning attendees planned to disrupt the event.
JNS
June 4, 2026

World
Israel & Middle East
Israel’s Noam Bettan places second behind Bulgaria at Eurovision
Noam Bettan ended his trilingual “Michelle” with “Am Yisrael Chai” before 160 million viewers, defying boos and a five-country boycott.
Steve Linde
JNS
May 21, 2026

World
Israel & Middle East
What Yom Yerushalayim should mean to American Jews
Jerusalem Day marks the city’s 1967 reunification. What should that moment mean to Jews in America today?
Stephen M. Flatow
May 14, 2026
© 2026 The Jewish World · Since 1965 - The Capital Region's gateway to Jewish life
Designed and Developed by Ta-Da Studios
© 2026 The Jewish World · Since 1965 - The Capital Region's gateway to Jewish life
Designed and Developed by Ta-Da Studios
© 2026 The Jewish World · Since 1965 - The Capital Region's gateway to Jewish life
Designed and Developed by Ta-Da Studios
© 2026 The Jewish World · Since 1965 - The Capital Region's gateway to Jewish life
Designed and Developed by Ta-Da Studios
